We analize the '2 faces' of the Bah, Bah a black Sheep rhyme. I mean 2 faces, because we saw the babies rhyme that Tommy Thumb's Pretty wrote and an image of the poem. The thing is that reading the poem and watching the image you know that there is no relation between them, and they are very different. Why this happened? Maybe because the tone that we read the poem isn't the correct one...
Following I will answer some questions of the page 165.
1)How is the tone different in the two stories?
In the image the tone is more like seriuos, nostalgic maybe. And in the rhyme, the tone is more like happy, light, mainly addressed to children.
2)What are the limitations of tellin a story only with words?
The problem is that the tone plays an important role in what we write, and if the person read it with the wrong tone, or if they don't catch the tone, they may understand something completly different in comparison with the real meaning or intension.
3)If you saw the image without the rhyme, what would you say are the limitations of image as a means of storytelling?
Really I would don't know what is the image trying to tell.
4)Must a story always change when transferred from one medium to another?
Yes! Because that trasference should imply the understanding or the point of view of a person about what an image/text is trying to express.
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario